A Review of Maggie Smith’s Goldenrod

I am writing this on a Sunday morning as Hurricane Ida begins to bear down on Louisiana. I am three hours east of New Orleans, and the tame shreds of Ida’s outer bands are now slapping the windows. My children are still asleep in their beds, having not been woken by the tornado warning announcement screeching from my phone. And, they are, for the moment, still healthy—in the midst of a pandemic surge that is ravaging our community and schools with all the violence of a Category 5.

These things are on my mind as I again pick up Maggie Smith’s latest poetry collection Goldenrod. I bought it several weeks ago when it came out. Like many, I first encountered Smith when her poem “Good Bones,” first published in Waxwing in 2016, went viral following the Pulse nightclub shooting. The climactic trope of the poem is that, like a desperate realtor, the speaker tries to “sell” this crumbling, broken world to her children as salvageable, a fixer-upper of sorts. “This place could be beautiful,/right? You could make this place beautiful,” she insists, and I found myself weeping at Smith’s echo of the simultaneous despair and hope that every day as a parent brings me.  

As the rest of 2016 unfolded, the poem only became more prescient. Now in 2021, the poems in Goldenrod find themselves at another apocalyptic intersection, both global and personal. Smith is keenly aware that other mothers’ babies are in cages (“Tender Age,” “Animals”), other mothers’ sons shot senselessly (“Airplanes”) as she looks at her own children. The pandemic and Smith’s divorce permeate the collection with an ache of loss that leaves room for something new: there are good bones left, even at the apparent end of the world. Smith neither wallows in doom nor proposes a pat solution: in “Wild,” the speaker admits, “I’ve talked so much about loving the world/without any idea how to do it.” Yet these poems are a love letter to this broken world, and their subjects range from the stars to the contents of her son’s pockets.

This is a book full of wordplay, philology, and topography; its various mappings range from a children’s atlas, to a smartphone’s autocorrect suggestions, to a planetarium, to the jagged curve of last year’s coronavirus graph. Yet its true subject is ultimately ineffable, unmappable: Goldrenrod is at once a taxonomy of existence and a meditation on those things that defy or destroy structure. These poems are fixated on the idea of home in the broadest sense, though it is at home that we are most likely to feel the Otherness of ourselves. Likewise, it is in naming things that we most notice the inadequacy of our words, our categories. Good poetry has always probed this paradox, and these poems invite those epic questions into an intimate, honest exploration that somehow hedges both  sentimentality and bitterness. While the world is “not waxing pastoral. There is too much/now at stake” (“in the Grand Scheme of Things”), these are nevertheless deeply pastoral poems, rooted in the particularity of local and domestic spaces that have so much at stake themselves. And the faith that emerges from these poems is not glib—it is prompted by doubt: in “Confession,” the speaker does confess, “My son’s terrible fevers are softening me/to God.” In “Invisible Architecture,” she asks, “what is held/by this scaffolding/I can’t yet see?”

And it’s hard to see the scaffolding these precarious days. I think about my own children, safe (for now), while other mothers’ children are in the path of a storm or lie in hospital beds. My children will inherit a broken climate and a broken nation. It is easy to despair in the face of so much danger, so much loss—and proper to mourn with those who mourn. But, as Smith says in “How Dark the Beginning,” “let us/talk more of how dark/the beginning of a day is.” Indeed, all of these poems in some way peek around the edges of the known world; as the speaker admits in “Threshold,” “You want a door you can be/on both sides of at once.” I know that I can’t be on both sides. But poetry helps me to survive and sometimes celebrate these liminal spaces, anticipating the other side through my dread, enabling me to “see” Others, as in the book’s titular poem, and recognize myself. In the book’s arguably most moving poem, “Bride,” the speaker finds her identity not in the conventions that have previously defined her, but in herself: “I am my own bride/lifting my veil to see/my face. Darling, I say,/I have waited for you all my life.” Likewise, in “At the End of my Marriage, I Think of Something My Daughter Said about Trees,” when a tree is felled, the sky “colors the space blue/because now it can.” In this veil of darkness and in these storms, we can wait for these spaces, these selves, to become the colors they were meant to be.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: